When Less is More
A few years ago, after some home improvements, I set out to buy some new boards to build the walls of my succah (the temporary hut that Jews live in for seven days during the Festival of Succot). Not only had my succah area doubled but, due to the way the construction had been done, the original boards that I had always used in the past were now too tall. So off I went to look for some new ones. Living in Jerusalem there was no problem finding cheap succah boards for sale. In fact, the area that I ended up in seemed to consist of one carpentry shop after another, each storefront graced with a huge pile of boards ready to be carted away and built into someone’s succah.
And that is when the trouble began.
Every board was exactly the same height. One of the reasons that they were so cheap was because they were all of uniform dimensions, mass produced by a machine. Each one cut in exactly the same way and completely indistinguishable from the next. Which meant that they were all too tall for my needs.
At this point it really didn’t occur to me that this might end up being a particularly difficult exercise. I approached one of the stores and asked the owner if he could cut boards for me according to my specifications. Nothing seemed to be a problem so I excitedly started explaining to him how many boards I needed and how tall they had to be. At first I rather naively thought that my boards, being about a third shorter than the ones being sold, were going to cost a third less than the going rate for the standard size, so you can imagine my amazement when the storekeeper quoted me a price that was almost double the regular price. Not wanting to pay any more than I had to, I asked around in some of the other stores and, more or less, I got the same answer everywhere. It transpires that in the mysterious world of succah boards, less is actually more!
Not having any real alternative, I went back to the first store and made my order. A few days later I returned to collect my newly shortened boards, bring them home and begin the putting them all together.
It was, in my humble opinion, a very beautiful and spacious succah. We enjoyed every moment that we spent in it. We ate all our meals in it, learned Torah in it, had lots of guests in it and we slept in it each night. My children especially enjoyed lying down on their camp beds in the darkness looking at the twinkling stars that peeked through the "holey" covering serving as a roof.
Late one night while I was sitting in the succah it suddenly occurred to me that sometimes the world of mitzvahs and the world of succah boards coincide with each other. We are commanded every year to leave our permanent homes and spend a week in a temporary abode. What is the reason? Among other things it is to instill in us an appreciation that ultimately almost everything in this physical world of ours is transient. The only commodities that have eternal value are
Who doesn’t want a beautiful residence? The Torah’s description of such a dwelling is a home dedicated to fulfilling
What Succot and the succah are teaching us is that to build such a palace requires that we take a "time out" from the physical world so that we can remember where all our blessings really come from. We divest ourselves of some of our material trappings so that we can recognize just how close we really are to
What that means is that in the long run — less really does become more!