Having trouble viewing this site? Try going to mobile.ohr.edu
ohr.edu
Ohr Somayach / Chanukah

WorldWide Branches
back to Holidays home pageback to Chanukah home page
Looking High and Low
by Rabbi Mendel Weinbach
The Connection Between the Maximum Height of a Menorah and the Depth of the Pit Yosef was Thrown Into
Looking High and Low by Rabbi Mendel Weinbach

Two statements may sometimes appear side by side in the Talmud even though the only thing connecting them is that they have the same author. This seems to be the case of one statement quoting Rabbi Tanchum regarding how high a Chanukah lamp may be placed above street level and another citing his interpretation of a passage in Chumash (Bereishis 37:24) about the pit into which Yosef's brothers cast him.

A closer look at this second statement may, however, suggest a subtle link between the subjects of both statements. "The pit was empty, with no water in it," says the Torah, and Rabbi Tanchum asks why it is necessary to repeat that there was no water in it if we have already been informed that it was empty. His conclusion is that the Torah wishes to stress that the pit was empty only of water but that it was inhabited by snakes and scorpions which miraculously did not harm the righteous Yosef.

"Were his brothers aware of the presence of these deadly creatures?" asks Rambam. If so, they certainly would have been so impressed with this Heavenly sign of Yosef's righteousness that they would have ceased conspiring against him. His conclusion is that because the brothers were so high above the bottom of the pit where these creatures crept they did not notice them.

Now, suggests one of the commentaries, we may see a link between Rabbi Tanchum's two statements. The Chanukah lamp, which is supposed to publicize the Chanukah miracle, cannot be noticed by those walking below if it is more than 20 cubits high. Yosef's brothers, on the other hand, could not notice the dangerous creatures at the bottom of the pit because it was too far below them.

(Shabbos 22a)



printable version
© Ohr Somayach International

Buy audio tapes by Rabbi Mendel Weinbach
Subscribe!

Get new
articles from
Ohr Somayach sent to your
inbox

 

also on ohr.edu


Is Classical Music in
Harmony with Judaism?
Breaking The Barriers
Breaking The Barriers
Of Bombs and Burials
Of Bombs & Burials
 

WorldWide Branches
ohr somayach
contact us
donate
apply online for courses
email subscriptions



TalmuDigest - by Rabbi Mendel WeinbachLove of the Land - by Rabbi Mendel Weinbach
Seasons of the Moon - Photography by Rabbi Yaakov Asher Sinclair

© 1995-2008 Ohr Somayach International
Ohr Somayach International is a 501c3 not-for-profit corporation (letter on file) and your donation is tax deductable.