The Weekly Daf

11 - 17 Sivan 5757 / 16 - 22 June 1997

Me'ilah 5 - 11

by Rabbi Mendel Weinbach zt'l
The Color of HeavenArtscroll

Two Views of the Holy Ashes

Take a look in your siddur (prayer book) and you will see in the very early part of the shacharis morning service a chapter from the Torah (Vayikra 6:1) which describes the first service performed by the kohanim each day in the Beis Hamikdash. After washing his hands and feet in the special basin in the Temple courtyard, a kohen would take a silver shovel, go up to the altar where the coals and ashes from the consumed sacrifices were gathered, and scoop up some of the most consumed ashes which he would then place on the floor next to the altar ramp.

This ritualistic "lifting of the ashes" was followed by an assault upon the large pile of remaining ashes by his fellow kohanim. They raked and shoveled these ashes into the center of the altar where they formed a dome similar to the shape of an apple. When this "apple" grew to such a size that it interfered with the activities of the kohanim it would be removed by the kohanim.

What is the status of these ashes in the "apple"? If someone takes some of them for private use is he guilty of me'ilah because he has misappropriated sacred property, or do we view these ashes as something whose mitzvah has already been completed and therefore no longer subject to the ban of me'ilah?

If he takes these ashes from the "apple" before the ritualistic lifting of the ashes the ban of me'ilah certainly applies because that mitzvah has still not been performed. But if this ritual has been completed and all that is left to do with the remaining ashes is to remove them to somewhere "outside the camp" there are two ways of viewing these ashes. The Sage Rav views this subsequent removal of the ashes not as a religious service but simply as a practical elimination of an impediment. Since all mitzvos have already been done with these ashes they no longer have a sacred status subject to the laws of me'ilah. Rabbi Yochanan takes an opposing view. Since the kohanim who remove these ashes must wear the special garments of a kohen, albeit less expensive ones than for other services because of the less esthetic nature of this action, we look at these ashes as still maintaining a sacred status because there is still a mitzvah to be done with them. Me'ilah, therefore, still applies.

  • Krisos 9a

Mystery of the Holy Wine

Wine which was poured as a nesachim libation on the altar as an accompaniment to a sacrifice is considered sacred and subject to the laws of me'ilah until it enters the ducts on the altar; from then on me'ilah no longer applies.

This rule stated in our Mishnah recalls a dispute in Mesechta Sukkah (49a) about the nature of these ducts into which the wine libations were poured. Several sages contend that these ducts went from the altar all the way to the watery depths of the universe. Rabbi Elazar bar Tzadok's opinion is that they ended at the internal base of the altar and once every 70 years some young kohanim would climb down a narrow passageway between the altar and the ramp leading to it and retrieve the wine which had congealed like pressed figs. They would then burn this congealed wine in the Sanctuary because it still had a sacred status.

Both of these views present a problem in regard to understanding our Mishnah. The first view presents a practical challenge - if the wine went all the way down to the depths, what need is there to mention that they are not subject to me'ilah after entering the ducts? While this is not a problem for Rabbi Elazar's approach, since the wine was retrievable, there is a different challenge - why is this wine not subject to me'ilah if it is considered sacred enough to require burning within a sacred area?

The resolution which is offered for both of these problems, both here in our Gemara and also in Mesechta Sukkah, is that our Mishnah deals with a case where the kohen placed his hand in the duct and caught the wine before it went all the way down. In such an event there is no longer a problem for the first approach as to how the wine is still around for discussion as to whether me'ilah applies. Rabbi Elazar's explanation is that once the wine has entered the ducts its mitzvah has been complete so that me'ilah no longer applies. Should the wine reach the base of the altar, however, it is once again sanctified by the contact with the Temple floor and requires burning in a sacred place. Since it was caught before that it has no sanctity and is exempt from the laws of me'ilah.

  • Me'ilah 11b

© 1995-2014 Ohr Somayach International - All rights reserved.

Articles may be distributed to another person intact without prior permission. We also encourage you to include this material in other publications, such as synagogue or school newsletters. Hardcopy or electronic. However, we ask that you contact us beforehand for permission in advance at ohr@ohr.edu and credit for the source as Ohr Somayach Institutions www.ohr.edu

« Back to The Weekly Daf

Ohr Somayach International is a 501c3 not-for-profit corporation (letter on file) and your donation is tax deductable.