Ohr
Somayach /
Rosh Hashana1 Tishrei 5760 / September 11, 1999
Rosh Hashana Page | Ohr Somayach Home Page |
|||
|
Rosh Hashana Page | Ohr Somayach Home Page |
![]() Selections from classical Torah sources which express the special relationship between the People of Israel and Eretz Yisrael Why Not Egypt?
"For the land which you come there to inherit is not like the land of Egypt from which you have gone out..." (Deuteronomy 11:10) Why was it necessary to take the Jews out of Egypt? G-d could simply have destroyed the Egyptians as punishment for their grave sins in enslaving and oppressing Israel and then given their land — a rich, fertile one — to His chosen people? The answer is supplied in the contrast between Egypt and the Land of Israel described in the ensuing passages. Egypt is irrigated once annually by the Nile and does not depend on rainfall, while the Land of Israel is dependent all year round on rainfall that comes as a result of special Divine Providence. It is therefore not a land with just one annual "visit" of G-d, but "a land which G-d seeks constantly, G-d’s eyes are upon it from the beginning of the year until the end of the year." The next passage explains the ongoing relationship of the Jewish People and G-d: "if you will heed the mitzvos which I command you", then "I will give you the rain for your land in its time." The Jewish existence in the Land of Israel is a special one, giving us the opportunity to be in constant interaction with G-d, with regular reward from Him for our Divine service. |
Rosh Hashana Page | Ohr Somayach Home Page |

Aaron Ahuvia wrote:
Rosh Hashanah will soon be with us, and this year we will not be blowing the shofar on the first day because it is Shabbat. I would like to understand more deeply why we have this custom. Is it because we don’t use ritual objects on Shabbat? But we read from the Torah on Shabbat? Or is it forbidden like other musical instruments, since if they break you might come to fix them? But how likely is it that a shofar will break?
Dear Aaron,
You’re right, there’s no prohibition against using ‘ritual objects’ on Shabbat. As you said, we read the Torah scroll on Shabbat.
Is the shofar forbidden on a ‘Shabbat Rosh Hashanah’ because of the prohibition against musical instruments? That can’t be the only reason, and here’s why not:
True, on a regular Shabbat, musical instruments - including shofars - are forbidden. But musical instruments are forbidden on Rosh Hashanah, also. So obviously, the mitzva of blowing shofar on Rosh Hashanah is an exception; otherwise, the mitzvah of shofar could never be fulfilled.
Rather, the reason is as follows: Everyone wants to fulfill his obligation to hear the shofar, but not everyone knows how to blow the shofar. Someone might bring his shofar to an expert to learn how, and thereby accidentally desecrate Shabbat by carrying the shofar outside.
I once heard a beautiful idea which can be learned from this Rabbinic decree, an idea especially appropriate for Rosh Hashanah:
One might ask: "How often will it happen that someone forgets it’s Shabbat and carries a shofar outside?"
Not very often.
"How learned is the person for whom the Sages made this decree?"
Not necessarily so learned.
"And how Jewish is the community in which this person lives?"
Not very. There’s not even a synagogue where he can go to hear the shofar blowing.
Nevertheless, the Sages of Israel forfeited their own mitzva - sacrificing their own spiritual elevation and that of the entire nation - for the sake of a simple, perhaps unlearned Jew, living far from the hub of any major Jewish community. They cared about him, concerned that he, too, keep Shabbat properly. This highlights the inseparable connection shared by all Jews, that we should care about each other and unite as one people.
As to your question, "How likely is it that a shofar will break?" I don’t know, but it so happens that last year on Rosh Hashanah my shofar broke. I fixed it after Rosh Hashanah by soaking it in boiling water until it softened, then repaired it and let it harden.
Produced by the Office of Communications
Editor: Raphael Scott Leban
Production: Eliezer Shapiro
Light Insight: Yaakov Asher Sinclair
HTML Design: Michael Treblow
HTML Production: Eli Ballon